Choosing the right toilet involves balancing performance, comfort, and budget. The best overall pick is the TOTO Drake for its reliable siphonic flush and timeless design. For those seeking ADA compliance and easier accessibility, the HOROW T0338W stands out with its dual flush and chair height. Budget-conscious buyers will appreciate the Simple Project 21-Inch Tall Toilet for its affordability and ease of use. However, tradeoffs often include installation complexity, water efficiency, and comfort features. Keep reading to see how these options compare and find the best fit for your bathroom.
Get furniture and decor delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- The top-rated toilets combine reliable flushing technology with ease of maintenance.
- Comfort height and ADA compliance are key features for accessible, user-friendly designs.
- Dual flush models offer significant water savings but may come at a higher upfront cost.
- Compact and elongated shapes serve different space and comfort needs, influencing choice.
- Premium models prioritize sleek aesthetics and advanced features, justifying higher prices.
| toilet | Rough-in | Material | Flush Rate |
|---|---|---|---|
| TOTO Drake Two-Piece Elongated | — | — | 1.6 GPF |
| HOROW T0338W One Piece Toilet | — | — | — |
| Simple Project 21-Inch Extra T | 12 inches | — | 1.28 GPF |
| Superflo 21 Inch High Elongate | 12 inches | — | — |
| DeerValley Two-Piece ADA Compl | — | Porcelain | — |
| Casta Diva Elongated One Piece | — | Vitreous china | — |
| Simple Project 21 Inch Elongat | 12 inches | High-density ceramic | 1.28 GPF |
| 15 Inch Round Front Two Piece | 12 Inch | Ceramic | 1.28 GPF |
| DeerValley Elongated One-Piece | 12 inches | Ceramic | 1.1/1.28 GPF |
| DeerValley Compact One Piece T | 12 inches | Ceramic | 1.1/1.6 GPF |
| One Piece Sleek Modern Toilet | 12 inches | Ceramic | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
TOTO Drake Two-Piece Elongated 1.6 GPF Universal Height Toilet with CEFIONTECT, Cotton White
This TOTO Drake model stands out for its combination of power, efficiency, and comfort. Its Tornado flush system ensures thorough waste removal, outperforming many standard toilets like the DeerValley 12″ model in flushing strength. The universal height makes it accessible for most users, balancing comfort with ADA compliance, though it may require professional installation due to its plumbing needs. The CEFIONTECT glaze reduces staining and makes cleaning easier, which is a significant advantage over models without such coatings. However, the need to purchase installation components separately adds to the total cost, and its modern style may not suit traditional bathroom aesthetics. Overall, this pick suits homeowners seeking high performance and ease of maintenance.
Pros:- Powerful Tornado flush for thorough cleaning
- Water-efficient at 1.6 GPF
- Universal height for comfort and ADA compliance
- Stylish modern design
Cons:- Requires separate purchase of installation components
- Professional installation recommended due to plumbing setup
Best for: Homeowners looking for a reliable, high-performance toilet with a sleek design and easy maintenance.
Not ideal for: DIYers or those on a very tight budget, since it may require professional setup and additional parts.
- Flush Rate:1.6 GPF
- Trap Seal:2-1/8″
- Minimum Water Pressure:8 psi
- Rough-In Size:12 inches
- Color:Cotton White
- Height:Universal Height
Our verdict“This toilet offers a balanced mix of power, efficiency, and comfort, ideal for those prioritizing performance and style.”
HOROW T0338W One Piece Toilet with ADA Chair Height 17.3″ Dual Flush
This HOROW one-piece toilet is designed with accessibility in mind, offering a comfortable 17.3-inch ADA height that surpasses standard models like the DeerValley 12″ for easier sitting and standing. Its dual flush system delivers water savings, especially compared to traditional single-flush toilets, making it ideal for eco-conscious users. Its compact footprint allows installation in tight spaces, though assembly may challenge some DIY users, and its limited color options could restrict style coordination. Compared with the Simple Project 21-Inch Tall Toilet, this model’s sleek one-piece design simplifies cleaning and maintenance. While its height and dual flush are definite advantages, the need for assembly and potential installation complexity are tradeoffs. This model is best for those prioritizing accessibility in smaller bathrooms.
Pros:- Comfortable ADA chair height for easy use
- Water-saving dual flush system
- Compact size fits small bathrooms
- Easy to operate flushing options
Cons:- Requires assembly and installation effort
- Limited color choices
Best for: Individuals with mobility challenges or those fitting a small bathroom who want an accessible, water-saving toilet.
Not ideal for: Homeowners seeking a traditional look or those unwilling to assemble and install a more complex unit.
- Dimensions:26.6″D x 15″W x 26″H
- Seat Height:17.3″
- Flush Options:1.1/1.6 GPF
- Trapway:2″ fully-glazed siphon
Our verdict“A practical, space-efficient option that enhances accessibility with water-saving features, suited for small or mobility-challenged users.”
Simple Project 21-Inch Extra Tall Toilet for Seniors and Handicap
This 21-inch tall toilet is tailored for comfort and ease of use, especially for seniors, pregnant women, and those with mobility challenges, contrasting with the more modern look of the DeerValley 21″ Tall Toilet. Its height reduces strain during sitting and standing, while the soft-close seat minimizes noise and potential injury. The 1.28 GPF flush balances water efficiency with effective cleaning, though its design may not appeal to those seeking a contemporary aesthetic. Installation is straightforward with included instructions, but the limited rough-in compatibility (12 inches) and less modern appearance might deter some buyers. If comfort and accessibility are your top priorities, this model offers a quiet, effective solution for those specific needs.
Pros:- Extra tall height for easy transfer and comfort
- Quiet, soft-close seat
- Efficient 1.28 GPF flush
- Easy to install with clear instructions
Cons:- Design may not suit modern bathrooms
- Limited to 12-inch rough-in compatibility
Best for: Elderly users, pregnant women, or individuals with mobility issues needing a taller, safer toilet.
Not ideal for: Design-conscious buyers or those with modern aesthetic preferences, due to its traditional look.
- Height:21 inches
- Rough-in:12 inches
- Flush Rate:1.28 GPF
- Seat Type:Elongated with soft-close technology
Our verdict“A comfort-focused toilet designed specifically for those needing a taller, accessible option, with quiet operation and reliable flushing.”
Superflo 21 Inch High Elongated Tall Toilet
The Superflo 21-inch tall toilet offers a generous height for those who find standard toilets uncomfortable, especially tall users and seniors, contrasting with the more feature-rich Simple Project model. Its easy-to-clean elongated bowl and soft-close seat add convenience, though its single flush technology (1.28 gallons) may not match the latest efficiency standards of some dual-flush options. Its straightforward design simplifies installation, but its focus on height limits its appeal to shorter users or those seeking a more modern aesthetic. This model excels in providing a comfortable, hygienic experience for taller individuals, though it sacrifices some advanced features found in premium models.
Pros:- Extra tall height enhances comfort
- Soft-close, quiet seat
- Easy installation process
- Reliable flushing performance
Cons:- Limited to single flush technology
- Designed specifically for tall users, not adjustable
Best for: Tall users and seniors prioritizing comfort over complex features or aesthetic variations.
Not ideal for: Younger, shorter users or those wanting dual-flush technology for water savings.
- Height:21 inches
- Rough-in:12 inches
- Flush Volume:1.28 gallons per flush
- Warranty:2 years
Our verdict“A comfortable, height-optimized toilet tailored for tall and senior users, with straightforward functionality and quiet operation.”
DeerValley Two-Piece ADA Compliant Toilet with Power Flush, 12″ Rough-In, 1.28 GPF, Comfort Height, White
This DeerValley model offers a reliable ADA-compliant height and a powerful flush system, making it a practical choice for budget-conscious buyers who need a compliant and effective toilet. Its spiral scrubbing jets and 1.28 GPF efficiency outperform older, less advanced models, though it doesn’t include features like bidet functions or a soft-close seat. Compared with the more modern, sleek designs of the Hornow or Simple Project models, this toilet has a more traditional appearance, which may not suit all aesthetic preferences. Its one-year warranty is shorter than some premium options, but overall it delivers dependable performance at a lower cost, suitable for basic upgrades.
Pros:- ADA compliant height for comfort and accessibility
- Powerful flush with spiral scrubbing jets
- Water-efficient at 1.28 GPF
- Simple, durable design
Cons:- Limited warranty period of one year
- No additional features like bidet or soft-close seat
Best for: Budget-conscious homeowners seeking a dependable, ADA-compliant toilet with good flushing power.
Not ideal for: Design-oriented buyers or those wanting extended warranty coverage and premium features like bidets.
- Rough-In Size:12 inches
- Water Flow Rate:1.28 GPF
- Height from Floor to Seat:17 13/16 inches
- Material:Porcelain
Our verdict“A solid, budget-friendly ADA toilet that delivers reliable flushing and comfort for everyday use, ideal for economical upgrades.”
Casta Diva Elongated One Piece Toilet with 17.2″ ADA Comfort Height Seat
This one-piece design stands out for its combination of powerful, eco-friendly flushing and ADA-compliant comfort height. Unlike the DeerValley DV-1F0437, which emphasizes modern aesthetics, this model prioritizes ease of use with a 17.2-inch seat that reduces strain for seniors and those with mobility issues. Its air-pressure assisted flush system provides reliable performance without electricity, yet installation may demand professional plumbing skills, making it less suitable for DIYers. The water-saving 1.0 GPF meets EPA standards, though color options are limited to white. Ideal for accessible bathrooms and eco-conscious homes, this toilet balances performance with user comfort, but may require extra setup work.
Pros:- Powerful, air-pressure assisted flush system for reliable waste removal
- Comfortable 17.2-inch ADA height for easy sitting and standing
- Water-efficient 1.0 GPF performance reduces water bills
Cons:- Installation complexity may require professional help
- Limited color options (only white) restrict style choices
Best for: Accessibility-focused households and eco-conscious homeowners seeking a powerful, efficient toilet
Not ideal for: Renters or DIY enthusiasts who prefer simple installation or multiple color choices
- Brand:Casta Diva
- Model Number:CD-W001
- Material:Vitreous china
- Flush System:Air-pressure assisted, siphon jet
- Water Usage:1.0 GPF
- Seat Height:17.2 inches
- Installation Type:One-piece
- Color:White
- Dimensions:26.9″D x 15″W x 19.3″H
Our verdict“This toilet is ideal for those needing accessible, eco-friendly performance in a sleek one-piece design.”
Simple Project 21 Inch Elongated Extra Tall Toilet for Seniors
This extra tall toilet with a 21-inch height offers significant comfort improvements over standard models like the DeerValley DV-1F0437, especially for users with mobility challenges. Its elevated seat reduces knee and hip strain, making it a popular choice for seniors or taller individuals. The 1.28 GPF flush balances water efficiency with effective cleaning, though its increased height means shorter users under 5’4″ might struggle without a footstool. Installation requires a 12-inch rough-in, which may not fit all bathrooms, limiting flexibility. This model is less suited for small spaces due to its size but excels for those prioritizing comfort and accessibility.
Pros:- Elevated 21-inch height reduces joint strain and eases sitting/standing
- Water-efficient flush maintains cleaning performance
- Soft-close seat prevents slamming and noise
Cons:- May require a footstool for shorter users
- Limited compatibility with non-12-inch rough-in layouts
- Too tall for users unaccustomed to higher toilets
Best for: Seniors, tall adults, and those with limited mobility who need a higher seat for easier use
Not ideal for: Shorter users or homes with limited space where taller toilets won’t fit comfortably
- Height:21 inches
- Rough-In:12 inches
- Flush Rate:1.28 GPF
- Seat Type:Soft-close
- Material:High-density ceramic
- Number of Pieces:2
Our verdict“This toilet offers exceptional comfort for taller individuals and seniors, with some considerations for space and user height.”
15 Inch Round Front Two Piece Toilet, Compact White Ceramic Commode with Soft Close Seat, 1.28 GPF Siphonic Flush, cUPC Certified, 12 Inch Rough-In
This compact two-piece toilet is tailored for bathrooms with limited space, such as apartments or small powder rooms. Its 15-inch round front bowl fits comfortably where larger models can’t, providing a practical alternative to the bulkier options like the DeerValley DV-1F0437. The 1.28 GPF siphonic flush delivers solid performance while conserving water, though the two-piece design may require more maintenance compared to one-piece models. Its glazed ceramic bowl is easy to clean, making it a smart choice for tight spaces that demand efficiency but not extra size. However, it only suits 12-inch rough-in installations, restricting placement options.
Pros:- Space-saving round front bowl ideal for tight bathrooms
- Water-efficient 1.28 GPF siphonic flush ensures strong waste removal
- Includes soft-close seat for quiet operation
Cons:- Requires 12-inch rough-in, limiting flexibility
- Two-piece design may need more maintenance over time
Best for: Small bathroom spaces, apartments, or anyone needing a compact yet efficient toilet
Not ideal for: Homes with non-standard 10 or 14-inch rough-in measurements or those preferring one-piece designs for ease of cleaning
- Bowl Shape:Round Front
- Material:Ceramic
- Color:White
- Flush Rate:1.28 GPF
- Flush Type:Siphonic
- Seat:Soft Close
- Certification:cUPC
- Rough-In:12 Inch
Our verdict“This toilet offers a compact, efficient solution for small bathrooms but may involve a bit more upkeep than one-piece models.”
DeerValley Elongated One-Piece Toilet with ADA Chair Height Seat, DV-1F0437
This rimless, one-piece toilet emphasizes sleek aesthetics and water savings, making it a strong competitor to models like the Simple Project 21 Inch Tall Toilet. Its seamless rimless design creates a contemporary appearance and facilitates cleaning, while the dual-flush system offers options for water conservation without sacrificing performance. The ADA seat height of 17.5 inches improves accessibility, especially for those with mobility issues. However, its heavier ceramic construction can make installation more challenging for DIYers, and the limited color options reduce customization choices. This model is ideal for modern bathrooms seeking a stylish, high-efficiency fixture, but less so for those prioritizing lightweight or varied color options.
Pros:- Seamless rimless design for a modern, easy-to-clean look
- Dual-flush system saves water and enhances efficiency
- ADA-compliant seat height improves accessibility
Cons:- Heavy ceramic material complicates installation
- Limited color options restrict style versatility
- Requires 12-inch rough-in, limiting placement options
Best for: Design-conscious homeowners seeking a modern, efficient, ADA-compliant toilet
Not ideal for: DIY installers or users who prefer lightweight, easy-to-move fixtures or multiple color choices
- Model Number:DV-1F0437
- Material:Ceramic
- Flush Rate:1.1/1.28 GPF
- Rough-In:12 inches
- Seat Height:17.5 inches
- Bowl Shape:Elongated
- Color:White
- Nozzle Type:Dual nozzles
Our verdict“Ideal for those who want a stylish, dual-flush, ADA-compliant toilet with a sleek look, accepting the heavier weight and limited color palette.”
DeerValley Compact One Piece Toilet with Soft-Close Seat, Dual Flush, 12” Rough-In, Skirted Design
This compact one-piece toilet boasts a space-efficient design with a skirted exterior that simplifies cleaning, making it comparable to the Simple Project 21 Inch Tall Toilet but even more suited for tight spaces. Its dual-flush technology offers water savings, with 1.1/1.6 GPF options that can cut water use significantly. The soft-close seat enhances user experience by eliminating noise, and the complete kit makes installation straightforward, though some plumbing knowledge is helpful. Its 12-inch rough-in limits placement, but for small bathrooms, this model provides a practical, clean look with reliable performance.
Pros:- Compact, space-saving design ideal for small bathrooms
- Dual-flush system reduces water consumption
- Skirted exterior simplifies cleaning and maintenance
- Quiet soft-close seat for user comfort
Cons:- Installation may require plumbing experience
- Limited to 12-inch rough-in fitting
Best for: Small bathroom owners or renovators prioritizing space-saving and ease of cleaning
Not ideal for: Larger bathrooms or users seeking a taller or more traditional design, as it is optimized for restricted spaces
- Dimensions:24½”L×13⅜”W×28⅜”H
- Rough-In:12 inches
- Flush Rate:1.1/1.6 GPF
- Weight Capacity:250 lbs
- Material:Ceramic
- Seat Type:Soft-close
Our verdict“This toilet is perfect for small bathrooms seeking a sleek, efficient, space-saving fixture with easy maintenance.”
One Piece Sleek Modern Toilet, ADA Chair Seat Height 17″, Dual Flush 0.9/1.28 GPF, MAP 1000g, 12″ Rough-In, Compact Fully Skirted Round Toilet for Bathrooms
This fully skirted, one-piece toilet stands out for its seamless surface, making it exceptionally easy to wipe down and maintain compared to traditional models like the TOTO Drake, which has exposed trapways that can trap grime. Its 17-inch ADA height seat enhances comfort for taller users and seniors, offering better ergonomics than standard 15-inch models. The dual-flush system with 0.9/1.28 GPF options balances water savings with flushing power, though it’s slightly less water-efficient than the ultra-low flush options in some premium models. The compact design fits well in smaller bathrooms without sacrificing comfort, but installation may be complex if existing plumbing isn’t compatible, potentially requiring professional help. Its quiet, powerful flush reduces noise and minimizes clogs, yet the included accessories mean extra parts might be needed for a complete install. Overall, this toilet is ideal for those prioritizing hygiene, ease of cleaning, and a modern look, provided they’re comfortable with some installation considerations.
Pros:- Seamless fully skirted design simplifies cleaning and reduces dirt traps
- Comfortable 17-inch ADA height suitable for taller users and seniors
- Dual-flush system offers water savings without sacrificing flushing power
- Quiet, powerful flush minimizes noise and reduces clog risk
Cons:- Installation can be challenging without professional plumbing help
- Additional parts may be needed as it does not include water supply pipe or floor flange
Best for: Bathroom remodelers seeking a sleek, easy-to-clean toilet with ADA comfort height for taller users or seniors
Not ideal for: Homeowners with existing plumbing incompatible with a 12″ rough-in or those on a tight installation timeline
- Rough-In:12 inches
- Seat Height:17 inches
- Flush Options:0.9/1.28 GPF
- MAP:1000 grams
- Dimensions:25.5″D x 14.7″W x 27″H
- Material:Ceramic
- Installation:Includes bolt kit, hinge kit, water supply pipe connector, wax ring
Our verdict“This toilet makes the most sense for homeowners wanting a modern, hygienic, and comfortable option with easy cleaning, despite some installation hurdles.”
How We Picked
To select the best toilets for this roundup, I evaluated each model based on flushing performance, water efficiency, comfort features, ease of installation, and durability. I also considered user reviews and brand reputation to ensure reliability and long-term value. The ranking reflects a balance of these factors, prioritizing models that perform well across multiple criteria while catering to different needs—from accessibility to space-saving design. Ultimately, the aim was to identify toilets that offer the best mix of performance, value, and user experience for various types of buyers.| toilet | Material |
|---|---|
| TOTO Drake Two-Piece Elongated | — |
| HOROW T0338W One Piece Toilet | — |
| Simple Project 21-Inch Extra T | — |
| Superflo 21 Inch High Elongate | — |
| DeerValley Two-Piece ADA Compl | Porcelain |
| Casta Diva Elongated One Piece | Vitreous china |
| Simple Project 21 Inch Elongat | High-density ceramic |
| 15 Inch Round Front Two Piece | Ceramic |
| DeerValley Elongated One-Piece | Ceramic |
| DeerValley Compact One Piece T | Ceramic |
| One Piece Sleek Modern Toilet | Ceramic |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Toilets
When choosing a toilet, it’s important to consider several factors that impact daily use, maintenance, and overall satisfaction. Understanding these factors can help you avoid common pitfalls like selecting a model that doesn’t fit your space or one that consumes too much water. Balancing features such as comfort, efficiency, and price will ensure you find the best fit for your bathroom and lifestyle.Size and Space Requirements
Before purchasing, measure your bathroom space carefully. Compact models are ideal for small bathrooms, but they may sacrifice some comfort or flushing power. Conversely, larger, elongated toilets provide more seating comfort but require more space. Remember that standard rough-in sizes vary, so verify your existing plumbing before buying to avoid installation issues. Choosing the right size ensures your bathroom remains functional and comfortable.
Water Efficiency and Flush Technology
Modern toilets often feature dual flush systems that save water by offering a light or full flush option. While these models cost more initially, they can significantly reduce water bills over time. Siphonic flush toilets tend to be quieter and more effective at clearing waste, but some cheaper models rely on gravity alone, which might lead to clogs. Consider your household’s usage and water conservation goals when selecting a flush technology.
Comfort and Accessibility Features
Features like height, seat shape, and bowl design impact comfort, especially for elderly or disabled users. ADA-compliant models with chair-height seats make sitting and standing easier, reducing strain. Elongated bowls generally provide more comfort than round ones but may take up more space. Think about who will be using the toilet most often and prioritize features that enhance accessibility and comfort accordingly.
Ease of Installation and Maintenance
Some toilets are designed for straightforward DIY installation, while others may require professional help, adding to overall costs. Skirted or one-piece models tend to be easier to clean due to fewer crevices, whereas two-piece designs might be more accessible for repairs. Long-term maintenance involves considering parts availability and durability; choosing reputable brands can simplify repairs and spare parts sourcing.
Aesthetic and Style
Toilets come in a range of styles, from sleek modern to traditional. Matching your toilet’s design with your bathroom decor enhances overall aesthetic appeal. Compact and minimalist styles are popular in contemporary bathrooms, but ensure they don’t compromise on comfort or functionality. Balance style preferences with practical considerations like size, cleaning ease, and compatibility with existing fixtures.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I know if a toilet will fit in my bathroom?
Measuring your existing space is key before purchasing a toilet. Check the rough-in measurement, which is the distance from the wall to the center of the drainpipe, typically 12 inches but sometimes 10 or 14. Also, consider the overall size of the bowl and tank to ensure it fits comfortably without overcrowding your bathroom. If you plan to replace an existing toilet, matching the rough-in size minimizes installation surprises.
Are dual flush toilets worth the extra cost?
Dual flush toilets can significantly reduce water consumption by offering two flushing options: a light flush for liquids and a full flush for solids. If your household uses toilets frequently, these models can lead to noticeable savings on water bills. While they usually cost more upfront, the long-term savings and eco-friendly benefits often justify the investment, especially in larger households or environmentally conscious homes.
What is the most comfortable toilet height?
Most comfort-height toilets are around 17 to 19 inches tall, which is higher than traditional models. These are especially beneficial for seniors or individuals with mobility issues, as they make sitting down and standing up easier. However, they might not be suitable for small children or shorter users. Consider who will use the toilet most often when selecting the height to enhance comfort and safety.
How often should I replace my toilet?
With proper maintenance, a quality toilet can last 15-20 years or more. Signs that it’s time to replace include frequent clogs, leaks, or cracks, which can lead to water waste and costly repairs. Upgrading can also improve water efficiency and bathroom aesthetics. If your toilet is over a decade old and showing signs of wear, a replacement might be more cost-effective than ongoing repairs.
Should I choose a one-piece or two-piece toilet?
One-piece toilets tend to be more stylish and easier to clean because there are no seams or joints. Two-piece models are typically less expensive and easier to replace parts on, but they can be harder to keep spotless. Your choice depends on your priorities: if aesthetics and ease of cleaning are paramount, a one-piece may be better; if budget and repairability matter more, a two-piece could be the way to go.
Conclusion
For most homeowners, the TOTO Drake offers a reliable, all-around excellent choice that balances performance, comfort, and durability, making it the best overall pick. Budget-conscious buyers should consider the Simple Project 21-Inch Tall Toilet for affordability without sacrificing essential features. Those seeking a more accessible option will find the HOROW T0338W ideal with its ADA compliance and dual flush system. For premium styling and advanced features, the One Piece Sleek Modern Toilet appeals to design enthusiasts. Ultimately, your choice should reflect your bathroom size, budget, and specific needs, ensuring a satisfying upgrade for years to come.
Halloween Picks
Kalolary 11 ft Halloween Inflatable Archway Ghost House Tunnel
Jenaai 5.3-Foot Motion-Activated Halloween Animatronic Skeleton
Fun Costumes Creepy Twin Boys Halloween Animatronic
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
