TL;DR
Get furniture and decor delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Apartment Therapy writer Laura Wheatman Hill tested a steamer, a portable upholstery cleaner and a homemade vinegar, water and dish soap solution on separate cushions of the same couch. She and her son judged the homemade mixture most effective at removing dog odor, though the test was limited to one sectional and the report does not provide a controlled comparison.
Apartment Therapy writer Laura Wheatman Hill reported that a mixture of white vinegar, warm water and dish soap removed dog odor from her couch more effectively than a steamer or a portable upholstery cleaner in a three-method home test. Hill said both she and her son found the homemade solution the strongest performer, giving readers a low-cost option to try while underscoring that the result came from a test on one sectional, not a formal product comparison.
Hill tested each method on a different seat cushion or pillow from the same sectional. She vacuumed the cushions before testing and tried the methods back-to-back. For the before-and-after smell check, she removed each cushion and asked her younger son, whom she described as particularly sensitive to odors, to assess it. The report does not give a separate score for every method in the supplied material, though it lists a 3 out of 5 rating for the Bissell cleaner.
For the winning method, Hill mixed one-quarter cup white vinegar, three-quarters cup warm water and one tablespoon of dish soap in a spray bottle. She sprayed the cushion generously, scrubbed it with a microfiber cloth, misted it with plain water, wiped it again and let it dry. Hill said the solution was the most effective at neutralizing the odor for both her and her son, and required the least work of the three approaches.
Hill also used a Bissell Pet Stain Eraser cordless upholstery and carpet cleaner with the manufacturer’s recommended Pet Pro cleaning solution on a section favored by her dogs. She said the cleaner removed the dog odor, according to her son’s assessment, but left the cushions damp longer than she wanted and produced a lingering cleaning-product scent the next day. The steamer was the third method tested, but the supplied report does not include its procedure or results in detail.
A Low-Cost Option for Couch Odor
The report offers a practical comparison for people dealing with pet odor in upholstered furniture, where smells can persist even after routine vacuuming. Hill’s preferred method uses common household ingredients and, in her test, avoided the lingering cleaner fragrance and extended dampness she noticed with the portable machine. That makes the result useful as a starting point for readers who want to try a simple cleaning approach before buying or using a dedicated upholstery device.
The findings are a personal home test, not evidence that the mixture will work equally well on every sofa or type of odor. Fabric, cushion construction, how long the smell has been present and the source of the odor can all affect cleaning results. Readers should follow their couch maker’s care instructions and test a small, hidden area before applying any liquid across a cushion.
Products Worth Considering
Shark HydroVac MessMaster Corded Wet/Dry Vacuum, Mop & Self-Clean (WD161)
Bose SoundLink Flex (2nd Gen) Portable Bluetooth Speaker
Ring Wired Doorbell Plus (2nd Gen) and Chime (3rd Gen), Nickel Silver and White
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
How Hill Compared Three Methods
Hill said she began the test because she could not get the persistent “dog smell” out of her soft upholstered couch and wanted her home to smell fresher ahead of holiday visitors. Rather than compare separate products in different homes, she tried the methods on different cushions of the same sectional, vacuuming first and asking her son to provide a before-and-after smell check.
The approaches were a steamer, a Bissell portable cleaner used with its Pet Pro solution, and a homemade spray of vinegar, water and dish soap. Hill’s report says the portable cleaner removed the odor but left a product scent and damp cushions. Her conclusion favored the homemade solution for odor reduction and ease. She said she still planned to steam the whole couch afterward for what she described as additional sanitizing power; the supplied report does not establish that the steamer would sanitize the sofa or provide details on its performance.
“The simplest method ended up being the most effective for removing the dog odor.”
— Laura Wheatman Hill, Apartment Therapy
Limits of the Home Test
The report describes a single couch and a small number of cushions, with odor judged by Hill and one family member. It does not state that the cushions were randomly assigned, describe a standardized odor scale, or report measurements of odor before and after cleaning. The results therefore reflect the testers’ perceptions rather than a controlled comparison.
The supplied source material also omits the steamer’s specific method and outcome, making it difficult to compare that result with the other two approaches. It is not clear how the vinegar mixture performs on different upholstery fabrics, older or stronger odors, or stains, and the report does not establish whether the mixture is safe for every couch. The article advises readers to check their furniture’s care guidance before cleaning.
Check Fabric Care Before Cleaning
Hill said she planned to use the steamer across the rest of her couch after trying the homemade mixture. The supplied report does not say whether she completed that follow-up or what effect it had on odor. For readers considering the recipe, the immediate next step is to check the sofa’s care label or manufacturer instructions and test the solution on an inconspicuous spot before treating a visible cushion.
Any broader conclusion would require testing on more couches, fabrics and odor conditions, with consistent application and drying times. Until then, Hill’s finding is best read as a useful personal result: the homemade mix worked best for her household’s couch, but it is not a guarantee for every upholstered sofa.
Key Questions
Which method did Hill say worked best?
Hill said a mixture of white vinegar, warm water and dish soap was the most effective at neutralizing dog odor in her test.
What was the recipe she used?
She combined one-quarter cup white vinegar, three-quarters cup warm water and one tablespoon of dish soap. She sprayed and scrubbed the cushion, misted it with plain water, wiped it again and let it dry.
Did the Bissell cleaner remove the odor?
Hill said her son confirmed the dog smell was gone after she used the Bissell with its recommended Pet Pro solution. She also reported that the cushion stayed damp and a cleaning-product scent lingered into the next day.
Was the test conducted on multiple sofas?
No. Hill tested the methods on different cushions or pillows from one sectional couch. The report does not describe a controlled test across multiple sofas or fabric types.
Can the vinegar mixture be used on any couch?
The report does not establish that the mixture is safe for every upholstery fabric. Check the couch’s care instructions and test a small, hidden area before applying it to a cushion.
Source: apartmenttherapy.com
