When it comes to upgrading outdoor storage with minimal hassle, the Astoria sheds stand out for their straightforward assembly and customizable options. The Astoria 12×20 Wooden Storage Shed shines with its spacious design and high walls, ideal for those needing large vertical storage. Meanwhile, the Handy Home Products Designer 12×10 Shed offers a stylish, complete package with windows and a floor, perfect for homeowners seeking both function and curb appeal. Both options, however, have their tradeoffs—such as extra costs for shingles or assembly challenges—that potential buyers should weigh carefully before making a decision.
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- The Astoria 12×20 offers expansive storage with high walls but requires additional purchases for flooring and shingles.
- The Handy Home 12×10 is a ready-to-assemble, stylish shed with included flooring and windows, suitable for those wanting a finished look.
- Both sheds are customizable with paint and shingles, but this adds to the overall build effort and cost.
- The larger Astoria shed provides more vertical space, while the Handy Home model is easier to set up and more complete out of the box.
- Tradeoffs include weight, potential weather restrictions, and the need for extra purchases or assembly time.
| Astoria 12×20 Wooden Storage Shed |  | Large, customizable outdoor storage with high walls | Size: 12×20 feet | Door Width: 5’-4” | Wall Height: 7’ | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Handy Home Products Designer 12×10 Wooden Storage Shed with Dormer, Windows, and Floor Kit |  | Stylish, complete shed with windows and floor included | Item Dimensions: 146″D x 120″W x 120″H | Item Weight: 1600 pounds | Floor Area: 120 square feet | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| astoria shed review easy build some flaw | Door Width | Size | Wall Height | Peak Height |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Astoria 12×20 Wooden Storage S | 5’-4” | 12×20 feet | 7’ | 9’-11” |
| Handy Home Products Designer 1 | 64 inches | — | — | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Astoria 12×20 Wooden Storage Shed
The Astoria 12×20 Wooden Storage Shed stands out for its massive internal volume and high side walls, making it excellent for those who prioritize maximum storage capacity. Its large doors with galvanized hinges promise durability and ease of access. However, since it doesn’t include a floor, buyers must budget for an additional purchase or installation, which complicates the build. Its customization potential with paint and shingles is appealing, but the need for extra steps and parts can extend the project timeline and cost. Due to weather restrictions, it’s not available in Florida, limiting its use in some climates.
Pros:- Large doors with galvanized steel hinges for durability
- High side walls and peak height maximize storage space
- Customizable with paint and shingles
Cons:- Floor not included, requiring additional purchase
- Not suitable for humid or storm-prone areas like Florida
- Requires separate purchase for shingles and paint
Best for: Buyers needing a spacious, customizable shed for large outdoor equipment or extensive storage.
Not ideal for: Homeowners looking for a ready-to-use, maintenance-free shed or those in humid or weather-sensitive regions like Florida.
- Size:12×20 feet
- Door Width:5’-4”
- Wall Height:7’
- Peak Height:9’-11”
- Material:Wood
- Floor Included:No
Our verdict“A spacious and customizable shed ideal for those with DIY skills willing to handle extra purchases and installation efforts.”
Handy Home Products Designer 12×10 Wooden Storage Shed with Dormer, Windows, and Floor Kit
This Handy Home Products Designer 12×10 Shed offers a compact yet stylish solution, with a complete floor kit and three screened windows. Its design incorporates a dormer and multiple access points—double doors and a side service door—making it highly functional. Compared to the Astoria 12×20, it’s easier to assemble and provides a finished look right away, but it’s also significantly smaller and less customizable in size. The shed’s weight (around 1600 pounds) might pose challenges during setup, and additional costs for paint and shingles apply, which can add to the overall project time.
Pros:- Includes complete floor kit and three screened windows
- Stylish design that enhances yard appeal
- Durable construction with wind and snow load resistance
Cons:- Assembly may take 4-8 hours and be challenging for some
- Heavy weight requires multiple people or equipment to move
- Paint and shingles sold separately, adding to costs
Best for: Homeowners seeking a stylish, ready-to-use shed that fits smaller backyard spaces and offers included flooring.
Not ideal for: Those needing extensive vertical storage or larger capacity, or buyers who want a completely customizable structure from scratch.
- Item Dimensions:146″D x 120″W x 120″H
- Item Weight:1600 pounds
- Floor Area:120 square feet
- Door Width:64 inches
- Door Height:70 inches
- Material Type:Wood
Our verdict“A well-designed, stylish shed with included flooring, perfect for small to medium yards where aesthetic matters alongside function.”
How We Picked
Our selection process focused on sheds that emphasize easy assembly, customizable features, and realistic tradeoffs. We examined product specifications, customer reviews, and manufacturer details, prioritizing options that balance build simplicity with practical flaws. The sheds had to be designed for DIY installation, with available accessories like shingles and paint, and be suitable for typical backyard conditions. We aimed to highlight differences in size, included features, and overall value to help potential buyers find the best fit for their needs.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Astoria Shed Review Easy Build Some Flaws
Choosing the right shed involves balancing size, features, ease of assembly, and your budget. The key is understanding what each shed offers and where compromises are made. For those with larger storage needs and DIY skills, the Astoria 12×20 provides maximum space but requires extra purchases and effort. Conversely, the Handy Home 12×10 offers a more complete package, ready to use but with less space and customization potential. Consider your climate, available space, and how much you’re willing to invest in assembly and finishing when making your choice.
Size and Capacity
The size of your shed determines how much you can store and how it fits into your yard. The Astoria 12×20 is best for those with large equipment or needing extensive vertical storage, but it demands more space and effort to assemble. The Handy Home 12×10, while more limited in capacity, is easier to fit into smaller yards and is suitable for lighter storage needs.
Build and Customization
If you want a shed you can customize completely, the Astoria offers a blank canvas with its high walls and no floor, giving you flexibility in foundation and finishing. The Handy Home model is more of a turnkey solution, with a complete floor and a stylish design, ideal for those who value aesthetics and faster setup but less customization.
Ease of Assembly and Cost
The Handy Home shed is designed for easier assembly, though it still requires a few hours and help due to its weight. The Astoria, being larger, might take longer and need more tools or multiple people. Both sheds require additional purchases for shingles and paint, which should be factored into your overall budget.
Climate and Location Considerations
Weather restrictions impact availability and durability. The Astoria shed isn’t available in humid or storm-prone regions like Florida, and both units need appropriate finishing to withstand weather conditions. Planning for additional weatherproofing and protective finishes is essential regardless of your choice.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I assemble these sheds myself?
Yes, both sheds are designed for DIY assembly, but the level of difficulty varies. The Handy Home 12×10, with its included parts and smaller size, is generally more straightforward, potentially taking 4-8 hours for a typical homeowner with some experience. The Astoria 12×20, being larger and customizable, might require more time and help, especially since it involves handling large panels and possibly building a foundation.
Are the floors included with these sheds?
The Astoria 12×20 does not include a floor, meaning you’ll need to purchase or build one separately, adding complexity and cost. The Handy Home 12×10 comes with a complete floor kit included, making setup quicker and more straightforward for those seeking an all-in-one solution.
What about weather resistance and durability?
Both sheds are made from wood and designed to withstand typical outdoor conditions, but their durability depends heavily on finishing and location. The Handy Home shed’s wind and snow load resistance makes it suitable for harsher climates, whereas the Astoria’s weather restrictions, especially in humid regions like Florida, mean it may require additional protective treatments to last.
Can I add shingles and paint later?
Absolutely. Both sheds are meant to be customizable with shingles and paint, which are sold separately. Adding these finishing touches can improve weather resistance and aesthetic appeal but also increases the total project scope and costs.
Which shed is better for small yards?
The Handy Home 12×10 is more suitable for smaller yards due to its compact size and ready-to-use features. The Astoria 12×20, while offering more space, requires more planning and space to accommodate its larger footprint and higher walls, making it less ideal for limited yard areas.
Conclusion
For homeowners needing maximum storage capacity and willing to handle additional finishing work, the Astoria 12×20 is the best fit, especially if customization and space are priorities. Those seeking a quick, stylish, and more manageable project will find the Handy Home 12×10 more appealing, particularly if they prefer a shed that includes a floor and is easier to assemble. Consider your yard size, climate, and DIY confidence when choosing between these two options.
