If you’re searching for the best asphalt sealer, you’re likely looking for a product that protects your driveway or pavement from wear, weather, and cracks. The Henry HE532410 Driveway Asphalt Resurfacer stands out for its superior durability, while the Jetcoat Premium Driveway Sealer offers long-lasting protection with easy application. However, the tradeoffs often involve balancing cost against longevity and ease of use. Cheaper options may require frequent reapplication, while premium sealers often come with a higher price tag. Continue reading for an in-depth comparison of the top 10 asphalt sealers to find the best fit for your project.
Key Takeaways
- Premium sealers like Jetcoat provide longer-lasting protection but at a higher upfront cost.
- Water-based sealers such as MDMprint tend to be easier to clean and apply, ideal for DIYers.
- Crack fillers like Sikaflex-410 excel at repairing before sealing for better longevity.
- Higher coverage per gallon can save money, but quality varies significantly among brands.
- Ease of application and drying time are key factors influencing overall user satisfaction.
| asphalt sealer | Application | Volume | Color |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sikaflex-410 Asphalt Sealant | Filling cracks in asphalt surfaces | 108 fl. oz. | Black |
| Henry HE532410 5 Gallon Drivew | Resurfacing and sealing large asphalt areas | — | Black |
| MDMprint 5 gal. Asphalt Filler | Asphalt filler and sealer | 5 gallons | Black Brown |
| Sikaflex-410 Asphalt Sealant | Crack filling in asphalt and concrete | 9 fl. oz. | Black |
| E-Z Stir Driveway Asphalt Fill | Driveway sealing and crack filling | 4.75 gallons per pack | Black |
| Red Devil 0637 Asphalt Crack F | — | 10.1 fl oz per cartridge | Black |
| Jetcoat Premium Driveway Seale | Ready to use, stir before application, apply with squeegee or brush | — | — |
| Henry Rubber E-Z Stir Driveway | — | — | — |
| Liquid Rubber Driveway Restore | Brushes or rollers | 4 gallons | — |
| Jetcoat Premium Elastomeric As | Cracks, holes, gaps, breaks | 1 Gallon | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Sikaflex-410 Asphalt Sealant, Black, Self-Leveling Hybrid Sealant for Filling Cracks in Asphalt Driveways, Roadways, and Pavements – 9 fl. oz. Cartridge, Pack of 12
This Sikaflex-410 stands out for its high-performance, self-leveling formula that simplifies crack filling on uneven asphalt surfaces. Unlike standard sealants, its hybrid composition offers excellent weather resistance and elasticity, making it suitable for both DIYers and professionals. The quick skin formation—less than an hour—speeds up repairs, yet it requires specific temperature conditions (65-75°F) to perform optimally. Compared to the Henry E-Z Stir, which is larger and easier for extensive projects, Sikaflex-410’s precision application makes it better suited for detailed crack repairs, though its limited crack width coverage (up to 1.5 inches) may be a drawback for larger issues. This pick is ideal for users seeking durable, weatherproof crack sealing in moderate climates but not for those working in extremely cold or hot conditions.
Pros:- Self-leveling for even application on uneven surfaces
- Weather-resistant and durable for outdoor use
- Quick skin formation accelerates repair process
- Ready-to-use without mixing
Cons:- Requires consistent temperature conditions (65-75°F) for best results
- Limited to cracks up to 1.5 inches wide
- Black color may mismatch some asphalt surfaces
Best for: DIY driveway repair projects and professionals needing reliable crack sealing on asphalt pavements
Not ideal for: Homeowners in very cold or hot climates, or those with wide cracks exceeding 1.5 inches
- Brand:SIKA
- Model:827839
- Color:Black
- Volume:108 fl. oz.
- Application:Filling cracks in asphalt surfaces
- Material:Hybrid sealant
- Pack Size:12 cartridges
- Coverage:Cracks up to 1.5 inches wide
Our verdict“This sealant is best suited for skilled DIYers and professionals focused on long-lasting crack repairs in moderate climates.”
Henry HE532410 5 Gallon Driveway Asphalt Resurfacer
The Henry HE532410 offers a straightforward solution for resurfacing entire driveways, making it ideal for homeowners tackling extensive asphalt projects. Unlike spot crack sealers such as Sikaflex, this product provides a uniform coating that restores and protects large areas, though it lacks the precision for detailed crack filling. Its 5-gallon size makes it cost-effective for big jobs, but the application process involves surface preparation and proper equipment, which may be a hurdle for casual DIYers. Compared with the smaller, more targeted products like Sikaflex-410, Henry’s resurfacer prioritizes coverage over detailed repairs, which means it’s less suitable for small cracks but excellent for overall driveway rejuvenation. This product makes the most sense for those wanting to renew large asphalt surfaces without focusing on minor cracks.
Pros:- Large quantity for extensive projects
- Provides a uniform, protective coating
- Cost-effective for big areas
- Suitable for sealing and resurfacing
Cons:- Requires proper surface preparation and application tools
- Not designed for detailed crack filling or small repairs
- Longer drying and curing time for full effectiveness
Best for: Homeowners restoring or sealing large asphalt driveways with extensive surface wear
Not ideal for: Users needing to fix individual cracks or seeking quick, small repairs
- Quantity:5 gallons
- Application:Resurfacing and sealing large asphalt areas
- Finish:Not specified
- Color:Black
- Type:Asphalt Resurfacer
- Drying Time:Variable
Our verdict“This resurfacer best serves large driveway projects where a smooth, protective finish is more important than crack-specific repairs.”
MDMprint 5 gal. Asphalt Filler and Sealer, Flat Finish, Black Brown, Water Base
The MDMprint 5-gallon asphalt filler and sealer provides a large-volume, water-based solution for sealing asphalt surfaces with a flat finish. Compared to Sikaflex-410, which is better suited for crack filling, this product emphasizes surface coating and filling over precise crack repair. Its water base allows for easier cleanup and application, making it appealing for DIY users managing multiple large areas. However, the lack of detailed drying and curing times might concern those planning specific schedules, and the flat finish may not be suitable for surfaces needing a glossy or textured look. This product is a good choice for extensive driveway sealing where ease of use and volume matter more than detailed surface matching or high-performance elasticity. It’s less ideal for detailed crack repairs or high-traffic areas requiring extra durability.
Pros:- Large 5-gallon size for extensive projects
- Water-based formula simplifies application and cleanup
- Provides a durable flat finish
- Affordable bulk option
Cons:- Limited information on drying times
- Flat finish may not match some aesthetic preferences
- No detailed customer feedback available
Best for: Homeowners sealing large driveways seeking a simple, large-volume solution
Not ideal for: Those needing precise crack filling or glossy surface finishes
- Volume:5 gallons
- Finish:Flat
- Color:Black Brown
- Type:Water Base
- Application:Asphalt filler and sealer
- Coverage:Large areas
Our verdict“This large-volume sealer suits homeowners with extensive driveways who prioritize easy application and a flat finish over detailed crack repair.”
Sikaflex-410 Asphalt Sealant, Black, 9 fl. oz. Cartridge
This Sikaflex-410 cartridge version emphasizes elasticity and adhesion, making it suitable for cracks that experience movement or expansion. Compared with the larger 12-pack, this smaller 9 fl. oz. cartridge offers greater precision for targeted repairs. Its flexible, elastic properties resist cracking and tearing over time, but the cure time of 7 days before water immersion or coating may slow down certain repair schedules. Surface preparation is essential, as it requires a clean, dry surface for optimal adhesion—similar to other high-quality sealants. Its single-component formula limits versatility but ensures ease of use. This product is best for users needing a flexible, weather-resistant sealant for cracks in driveways or pavements that are subject to movement but are not looking for quick curing or large-volume applications.
Pros:- Highly elastic and flexible to resist cracking
- Weather-resistant for outdoor durability
- Good adhesion to asphalt and concrete surfaces
- Easy to apply in targeted repairs
Cons:- Cure time of 7 days limits quick repairs
- Requires surface to be clean and dry before application
- Single-component formula may not suit complex repairs
Best for: Homeowners and professionals sealing cracks subject to movement or weather exposure
Not ideal for: Users seeking fast curing or large crack filling projects
- Brand:SIKA
- Model:621653
- Volume:9 fl. oz.
- Color:Black
- Application:Crack filling in asphalt and concrete
- Cure Time:7 days
Our verdict“Ideal for detailed, flexible crack repairs where weather resistance and elasticity are priorities over speed of cure.”
E-Z Stir Driveway Asphalt Filler/Sealer (4.75 gal – 2 Pack)
The E-Z Stir Driveway Filler/Sealer offers a practical, large-volume solution for sealing and filling cracks across extensive driveways. Compared to smaller, more precise sealants like Sikaflex-410, this product is designed for straightforward applications, making it suitable for homeowners with larger surface areas to cover. Its 4.75-gallon packs provide ample material, but application requires proper tools and preparation to avoid messiness, especially since it’s a liquid sealer. While it’s effective for general sealing needs, it’s not tailored for detailed crack repair or high-traffic, high-stress areas. This product makes the most sense for users seeking a simple, bulk application that covers large spaces quickly, though it sacrifices some precision and may be messy to apply without proper equipment.
Pros:- Two large containers for extensive coverage
- Effective at sealing and filling large areas
- Easy to apply with proper tools
- Good for DIY and professional use
Cons:- Potentially messy during application
- Limited to driveway sealing, not for detailed crack repair
- Requires proper tools and surface prep
Best for: Homeowners and contractors sealing extensive driveways with minimal detailed repair requirements
Not ideal for: Users needing precise crack filling or surface finishing in small areas
- Quantity:2 Pack
- Volume:4.75 gallons per pack
- Color:Black
- Application:Driveway sealing and crack filling
- Suitable for:Large surface areas
Our verdict“This large pack of sealer is perfect for extensive driveway projects where quick coverage is needed but not detailed repairs.”
Red Devil 0637 Asphalt Crack Filler Sealant – Black Acrylic Driveway Sealer, Pack of 4
This crack filler stands out for its ability to blend seamlessly with asphalt, creating a professional look that closely matches the driveway surface. Compared with products like Jetcoat Premium Driveway Sealer, which focuses more on surface sealing, the Red Devil is tailored for small crack repairs that need to be both flexible and water-resistant. Its acrylic formula adheres well even on damp surfaces, making it a reliable choice for humid conditions. However, its scope is limited to cracks and joints, requiring multiple cartridges for larger areas, and it doesn’t address surface sealing comprehensively. This pick is ideal for homeowners who need quick, precise crack repairs that blend in seamlessly. It’s less suited for those seeking a full driveway sealant or large-scale resurfacing.
Pros:- Blends seamlessly with asphalt for a clean, professional appearance
- Flexible to resist cracking and withstand weather conditions
- Adheres well to damp surfaces, suitable for wet or humid conditions
- Easy to apply with standard caulking guns
Cons:- Limited to cracks and joints, not suitable for large repairs
- Requires multiple cartridges for extensive areas
- Only compatible with asphalt surfaces
Best for: DIY homeowners needing effective crack filling that matches existing asphalt
Not ideal for: Property managers looking for full surface sealing or large-area repairs
- Volume:10.1 fl oz per cartridge
- Pack Size:4
- Color:Black
- Material:Acrylic
- Made in:USA
Our verdict“This sealant is best for detailed crack repairs where appearance and flexibility matter most.”
Jetcoat Premium Driveway Sealer, Asphalt Crack Filler and Sealant (5 Year Protection)
Compared with the Red Devil crack filler, Jetcoat Premium offers a broader approach by sealing entire asphalt surfaces while also filling cracks, making it suitable for driveway maintenance. Its polymer-modified emulsion formula provides a durable, slip-resistant coating that lasts up to five years, a significant advantage over products like Henry Rubber E-Z Stir, which focus solely on crack sealing. Yet, Jetcoat’s coverage varies depending on surface porosity, and it requires a second coat for optimal performance, adding time and effort. This makes it an excellent choice for homeowners seeking a long-term, hassle-free solution for protecting their driveway but less ideal for those only needing spot crack repairs.
Pros:- Long-lasting protection with a 5-year durability
- Easy to apply with ready-to-use formula
- Effective for sealing surfaces and filling cracks
- Provides slip resistance and added durability
Cons:- Coverage varies depending on surface porosity
- Requires a second coat for best results
- Not suitable for concrete or masonry surfaces
Best for: Homeowners wanting a comprehensive, durable driveway sealant with extended protection
Not ideal for: Users preferring quick, small repairs or working on concrete surfaces
- Coverage:250-350 sq. ft per pail
- Application:Ready to use, stir before application, apply with squeegee or brush
- Type:Asphalt crack filler and sealant
- Protection Duration:5 years
Our verdict“This product makes the most sense for homeowners prioritizing long-term surface protection and crack filling in asphalt driveways.”
Henry Rubber E-Z Stir Driveway Asphalt Filler/Sealer
This sealer is designed for fast, straightforward driveway repairs with its rubberized formula that ensures durability and weather resistance. It simplifies application compared to the Jetcoat, which requires a second coat, and is more suited for quick fixes rather than comprehensive sealing. Although detailed product specs are limited, its easy stirring and weather-resistant qualities make it appealing for homeowners who want a simple solution. However, it may need multiple coats for best results, and the lack of detailed information can be a drawback for those seeking precise application data. It’s a practical option for quick crack filling but less so for extensive resurfacing projects.
Pros:- Easy to stir and apply
- Provides durable sealing for driveways
- Weather resistant formula
Cons:- Limited product details available
- May require multiple coats for optimal results
- Less suited for large or detailed repairs
Best for: Homeowners seeking a fast, easy-to-apply driveway filler and sealer
Not ideal for: Those requiring detailed product specs or large-scale sealing projects
Our verdict“This pick is ideal for quick, hassle-free driveway repairs where ease and speed are priorities.”
Liquid Rubber Driveway Restore – Flexible Asphalt Coating for Cracks and Revitalization, 4 Gallons
Compared with the crack-focused products like Red Devil or Jetcoat, Liquid Rubber Driveway Restore is designed to rejuvenate and waterproof older asphalt surfaces. Its flexible, low-VOC coating can be applied with brushes or rollers, making it user-friendly for revitalization projects. The need for 2-3 coats and coverage of about 50 sq ft per gallon makes it more time-consuming, but it offers superior waterproofing and flexibility, which enhances longevity. This makes it especially suitable for aging driveways with cracks that need both sealing and surface renewal. However, the multiple coats required and the focus on asphalt-only surfaces mean it’s less ideal for quick repairs or concrete surfaces.
Pros:- Easy to apply with brushes or rollers
- Flexible, waterproof, and environmentally friendly
- Revitalizes and protects aging driveways
Cons:- Requires multiple coats for best results
- Limited to asphalt surfaces
- Coverage depends on application thickness
Best for: Homeowners with aging asphalt driveways needing waterproofing and surface renewal
Not ideal for: Users with limited time or those sealing large new cracks requiring quick fixes
- Volume:4 gallons
- Application:Brushes or rollers
- Coverage:1 gallon per 50 sq ft
- Coats:2-3
- Features:Flexible, waterproof, low VOC
Our verdict“This product is well-suited for revitalizing and waterproofing older driveways that need flexibility and surface renewal.”
Jetcoat Premium Elastomeric Asphalt Crack Filler and Sealant (1 Gallon)
Compared with the Red Devil, which excels at seamless crack filling, Jetcoat Premium emphasizes durability, flexibility, and quick drying for cracks and small holes. Its elastomeric qualities make it a strong choice for weather-resistant repairs that need to stay flexible over time. However, it requires stirring during application and a full 24 hours to dry, making it less convenient for urgent repairs. For large cracks, multiple applications might be necessary, which can increase the overall repair time. This product focuses on crack sealing rather than surface protection, making it ideal for maintaining the integrity of asphalt surfaces over time.
Pros:- Flexible and long-lasting sealant
- Suitable for multiple asphalt surfaces
- Easy to apply with included spout
- Dries quickly and resists tracking
Cons:- Requires stirring during application
- Needs 24 hours to fully dry
- Multiple applications may be necessary for large cracks
Best for: Homeowners needing durable, flexible crack repairs in asphalt driveways
Not ideal for: Users seeking a complete driveway surface sealant or quick fixes
- Volume:1 Gallon
- Application:Cracks, holes, gaps, breaks
- Suitable surfaces:Asphalt pavements, blacktop surfaces
- Drying time:24 hours
Our verdict“Ideal for crack repairs that require flexibility and durability in asphalt driveways, but less suited for quick surface sealing.”
How We Picked
The products in this roundup were selected based on their performance, durability, ease of application, and value. We prioritized sealers that are suitable for both DIYers and professionals, considering their ability to withstand weather and traffic over time. Products were ranked by comparing coverage area, drying and curing times, and user reviews, with an emphasis on how well they protect pavement from cracking and deterioration. We aimed to include a mix of budget-friendly options and premium picks to cater to different needs, ensuring each product offers a distinct advantage or role in asphalt maintenance.Factors to Consider When Choosing Asphalt Sealer
Choosing the right asphalt sealer involves several critical factors. Beyond just price, it’s important to consider the sealer’s durability, ease of application, compatibility with your surface, and whether it’s water-based or solvent-based. Understanding these factors can help prevent common mistakes like over-application or using a product unsuitable for your climate. A good sealer not only enhances appearance but also extends the life of your asphalt, saving money on repairs long-term. Keep these considerations in mind to select a product that aligns with your project scope and budget.Durability and Weather Resistance
Look for sealers that offer high resistance to UV rays, water, and temperature fluctuations. Products with elastomeric properties tend to bend and expand with the asphalt, reducing cracks. Cheaper options often fade or wear quickly, requiring frequent reapplications. Investing in a more durable sealer can be more cost-effective over time, especially for high-traffic or exposed surfaces.
Ease of Application and Drying Time
Sealers that are easy to apply, with smooth consistency and good flow, minimize mess and effort. Many products now feature ready-to-use formulas or require only simple tools. Pay attention to drying and curing times—faster drying options allow you to reopen your driveway sooner, but may require more precise application conditions to avoid streaks or uneven coverage.
Coverage and Cost-Effectiveness
Compare the coverage per gallon to determine overall value. Cheaper products might seem attractive initially, but if they require multiple coats or frequent reapplications, the cost adds up. Higher coverage rates with quality products can reduce total project costs, but be cautious of over-promising coverage—actual results depend on surface condition and application method.
Compatibility and Surface Preparation
Proper surface prep is essential—clean and repair cracks before sealing. Some sealers work better on new asphalt, while others are formulated for older surfaces. Water-based sealers generally dry faster and are easier to clean, but solvent-based options may offer superior adhesion and longevity in certain climates. Matching the product to your specific surface and local weather is key to lasting results.
Environmental and Safety Considerations
Water-based sealers tend to emit fewer fumes and are less harmful during application, making them safer for DIY use and in areas with limited ventilation. Solvent-based sealers often provide a more durable finish but require careful handling and proper disposal. Consider the environmental impact and your safety when choosing a product, especially if you plan to do the work yourself.
Frequently Asked Questions
How often should I reapply asphalt sealer?
The frequency of reapplication depends on the product used, traffic levels, and weather conditions. Typically, a good quality sealer lasts 3 to 5 years under normal conditions. Heavy traffic or harsh weather can shorten this lifespan, requiring more frequent reapplications. Regular inspections can help determine when it’s time for a fresh coat to maintain protection and appearance.
Can I apply asphalt sealer in rainy or humid weather?
It’s best to avoid applying sealer in rainy or overly humid conditions, as moisture can interfere with adhesion and curing. Many sealers require a dry, warm environment for optimal results. Applying in unsuitable weather can lead to uneven coverage, streaks, or a failure to cure properly, reducing the sealer’s effectiveness and longevity.
Is a water-based sealer as durable as solvent-based options?
While water-based sealers are easier to handle, less toxic, and quicker to clean up, they can sometimes be less durable than solvent-based options, especially in extreme weather conditions. However, advancements in formulation have improved their performance, making them suitable for many residential applications. Consider your climate and specific needs when choosing between these types.
What preparation is needed before applying asphalt sealer?
Proper surface preparation is vital to ensure the sealer adheres well and lasts long. This involves cleaning the asphalt thoroughly to remove dirt, oil, and debris, and repairing any cracks or potholes. Allow the surface to dry completely before application, typically 24 to 48 hours, depending on the product and weather. Skipping this step can compromise the sealant’s effectiveness and lifespan.
Can I seal over old, worn asphalt without repairs?
Sealing over old, heavily worn or cracked asphalt usually isn’t effective unless you first repair the surface. Fill in cracks and potholes, and clean the surface thoroughly. Applying sealer directly over severely damaged asphalt may result in poor adhesion and a shorter lifespan. For best results, consider a resurfacing or patching process before sealing for a smoother, more durable finish.
Conclusion
For most homeowners, the Henry HE532410 Driveway Asphalt Resurfacer offers a reliable balance of durability and ease of use as the best overall choice. Budget-conscious users will find the E-Z Stir Driveway Asphalt Filler/Sealer provides good coverage at a lower price point. Those seeking longevity and premium protection should consider the Jetcoat Premium Driveway Sealer, especially for high-traffic areas. Beginners benefit from water-based, easy-to-apply options like MDMprint, while professionals may prioritize high-performance products like Sikaflex-410 for crack repair. Tailor your choice to your project scope, climate, and budget for the best results.
